Companies that use deceptive tactics on online shoppers could face fines of up to 6% of their annual global revenue under the European Commission’s proposed Digital Fairness Act (DFA).
The draft would ban manipulative website designs, restrict advertising aimed at children and force subscription services to make cancelling easier.
Commissioner Michael McGrath, who presented the package alongside Executive Vice-President Henna Virkkunen, called it “the most significant reform of EU consumer protection rules in more than 20 years.” The DFA would replace the 2005 Unfair Commercial Practices Directive with a regulation applying directly across all 27 EU countries.
The heavy fines come through a parallel overhaul of the Consumer Protection Cooperation Regulation, which hands the Commission stronger powers to investigate large-scale breaches.
The Commission says unfair online practices cost Europeans €10.3 billion a year and that the package could save consumers up to €13.7 billion annually. Its impact assessment projects €88.4 billion in avoided consumer losses between 2025 and 2035, against recurring business costs of €678 million a year.
The proposal lists ten website and app designs that authorities could ban without proving consumer harm. These include fake stock warnings, preselected purchases, repeated pop-ups and cancellation hurdles. Hidden checkout charges and misleading discount claims are also in the firing line.
Subscription businesses would face new obligations: free trials could convert into paid contracts only after customers actively agree; services would also need easy online cancellation options and reminders before certain automatic renewals; and companies would also have to offer human customer services instead of relying purely on chatbots.
Ticket sellers using dynamic pricing would have to show how many tickets are available at the advertised price, along with the maximum possible price, before customers buy. Influencers would need to disclose their business relationships with brands.
Children and online users gain new protections
The DFA would extend the Digital Services Act’s ban on targeted advertising to minors, which currently covers only online platforms, to all websites and apps.
It would also restrict targeting of vulnerable consumers: video games could no longer offer paid loot boxes or pay-to-win purchases to children, and parents would need to approve paid in-game currencies for minors.
Additionally, users could switch off endless scrolling, autoplay, engagement streaks and notifications designed to keep them hooked.
The proposal also tackles chatbot features that simulate personal relationships to hold users’ attention. AI shopping agents would need to disclose sponsored recommendations and respect customers’ approval settings.
Consumer groups cheer as industry, Germany push back
The European Consumer Organisation (BEUC) welcomed the proposal as a way to rebalance the digital economy. Its director general, Agustín Reyna, singled out complex cancellations, opaque ticket pricing and pressure-inducing “low stock” warnings.
Some MEPs, however, say the Commission did not go far enough. Dutch Green MEP Kim van Sparrentak called the approach to addictive design a “historic mistake, both for our health and for our democracy,” according to EUPerspectives, arguing that users should get safer defaults instead of having to switch features off themselves.
Meanwhile, Maltese Socialist MEP Alex Agius Saliba regretted that addictive design was left off the banned list. Finance Watch’s Peter Norwood argued the safeguards “lack ambition” for online financial consumers.
The industry warns of the opposite problem. BusinessEurope, CCIA Europe and ITI say the DFA duplicates existing rules and clashes with the Commission’s own simplification agenda. The Interactive Advertising Bureau also estimates the new requirements could cause economic losses of €10 billion to €29 billion a year.
Germany’s Startup Association additionally warned the act “must not make scaling in Europe more expensive.”
Berlin had already questioned whether a new law was needed, favoring changes to existing consumer directives in an October paper. Finnish MEP Aura Salla of the center-right EPP made the same argument after the launch, though McGrath dismissed the complexity claims, saying the DFA makes unfair business harder—not business itself.
The European Parliament and EU governments must now negotiate the text before it becomes law. The proposal sets the rules to apply twelve months after they enter into force.
Featured image: Steve A Johnson via Unsplash+